The Unrelated Negative Meme
Upon request from the illustrious Viscount, whose own Unrelated Negative Meme will be hard to top, I am tackling only the first part of his UNM:
5 Bands I Used To Like But Don't Anymore:
Lynnrd Skynnrd
I admit it. I did actually like Skynnrd once. The guitar work on Sweet Home Alabama just tickles me good, and the song is kinda cool too. Aside from that, however, we've got Skynnrd to thank for "Ooooh That Smell", "Gimme Three Steps" and the godforsaken "Free Bird". I don't know why it took me until I graduated college to realize that these guys were just drunken rednecks playing to crowds of equally drunken rednecks. Maybe it had something to do with my mental state in college. Anyway, even in that genre, the only thing worse than Lynnrd Skynnrd is Post-Airplane Crash Lynnrd Skynnrd.
Chicago
Actually, I still love early Chicago stuff. Back when they were still the Chicago Transit Authority. I had a 4-disc live album when I was in high school that I wore out several turntable needles on. The interweaving of jazz horn arrangements with rock guitar and drums was novel and brilliantly done - stuff like "Ballet for a Girl in Buchanan" is timeless. Then one day they apparently handed over the creative reins to Peter Cetera and became the Chicago Corn Dog Authority.
Bob Dylan
Historical figure. Brilliant lyricist. Activist. Storyteller. Quirky stylist. He was all those things
and more, I suppose. Now he's toast. Saw him live last week at the New Orleans jazz festival and tried to feel the emotions associated with being in the presence of a rock deity. Instead, I felt the emotions associated with being in the presence of a croaking toad in a white cowboy suit . Dylan has reached a point in his career where he looks like shit, sounds like shit, his band sucks and his songs are boring. Other than that, he's great. Plus he's weirder than a three dollar bill which for some artists can be a good thing, but for this one is most definitely not.
Post-Beatles George Harrison
I'll probably take some flack for this (especially after dissing Dylan), but nothing George did after the Beatles moo -who -wooves me. I don't mind listening to some of it, but I own no post-Beatles George in my collection and I don't feel all that deprived in light of it. His melodies sometimes sound just wrong to me, his voice is not always appealing, and that prissy solo guitar tone he favors...well....he's done a lot better. I don't need to go into detail about the Traveling Dingleberries, either. Still, I have tremendous respect for his integrity and his ability to maintain his dignity through any situation - qualities he displayed throughout his entire life.
Colin Moulding
Now, pay attention to what I'm doing here. I am in no way disparaging or even lessening my admiration for XTC as a band. But in the past I would pick my way through earlier XTC albums to get to the Colin Moulding songs because they were always the high point on the CD for me. Lately however, they've become the low point. Colin, in my opinion, has lost his voice, and I don't mean his singing voice.
King For A Day, English Roundabout, I Remember The Sun and other priceless gems have given way to "The Smartest Monkeys" (great music, pretentious lyrics), "Frivolous Tonight", "Fruit Nut", "Board It Up", the unbelievably annoying "Standing in for Joe" and a host of other duds. Maybe it's time for Colin to hang up his spurs.
Fire away.
5 Bands I Used To Like But Don't Anymore:
Lynnrd Skynnrd
I admit it. I did actually like Skynnrd once. The guitar work on Sweet Home Alabama just tickles me good, and the song is kinda cool too. Aside from that, however, we've got Skynnrd to thank for "Ooooh That Smell", "Gimme Three Steps" and the godforsaken "Free Bird". I don't know why it took me until I graduated college to realize that these guys were just drunken rednecks playing to crowds of equally drunken rednecks. Maybe it had something to do with my mental state in college. Anyway, even in that genre, the only thing worse than Lynnrd Skynnrd is Post-Airplane Crash Lynnrd Skynnrd.
Chicago
Actually, I still love early Chicago stuff. Back when they were still the Chicago Transit Authority. I had a 4-disc live album when I was in high school that I wore out several turntable needles on. The interweaving of jazz horn arrangements with rock guitar and drums was novel and brilliantly done - stuff like "Ballet for a Girl in Buchanan" is timeless. Then one day they apparently handed over the creative reins to Peter Cetera and became the Chicago Corn Dog Authority.
Bob Dylan
Historical figure. Brilliant lyricist. Activist. Storyteller. Quirky stylist. He was all those things
and more, I suppose. Now he's toast. Saw him live last week at the New Orleans jazz festival and tried to feel the emotions associated with being in the presence of a rock deity. Instead, I felt the emotions associated with being in the presence of a croaking toad in a white cowboy suit . Dylan has reached a point in his career where he looks like shit, sounds like shit, his band sucks and his songs are boring. Other than that, he's great. Plus he's weirder than a three dollar bill which for some artists can be a good thing, but for this one is most definitely not.Post-Beatles George Harrison
I'll probably take some flack for this (especially after dissing Dylan), but nothing George did after the Beatles moo -who -wooves me. I don't mind listening to some of it, but I own no post-Beatles George in my collection and I don't feel all that deprived in light of it. His melodies sometimes sound just wrong to me, his voice is not always appealing, and that prissy solo guitar tone he favors...well....he's done a lot better. I don't need to go into detail about the Traveling Dingleberries, either. Still, I have tremendous respect for his integrity and his ability to maintain his dignity through any situation - qualities he displayed throughout his entire life.
Colin Moulding
Now, pay attention to what I'm doing here. I am in no way disparaging or even lessening my admiration for XTC as a band. But in the past I would pick my way through earlier XTC albums to get to the Colin Moulding songs because they were always the high point on the CD for me. Lately however, they've become the low point. Colin, in my opinion, has lost his voice, and I don't mean his singing voice.
King For A Day, English Roundabout, I Remember The Sun and other priceless gems have given way to "The Smartest Monkeys" (great music, pretentious lyrics), "Frivolous Tonight", "Fruit Nut", "Board It Up", the unbelievably annoying "Standing in for Joe" and a host of other duds. Maybe it's time for Colin to hang up his spurs.
Fire away.
posted by Soundsurfr at 6:59 PM
6 Comments:
Skynrd - Mostly agree but I can still listen to "Gimme 3 Steps."
Chicago - You are kinder to them than I would be.
Dylan - I agree post "Blood On The Tracks" but I still love his old stuff.
George - Solo work is disappointing, but for me it is mostly in the production. I'd love to hear more of his demos.
Colin - Agree mostly about his latest contributions. Like Dylan, it doesn't devalue his good work - just makes me wish he would still do good work!
Click here to download a beautiful version of "Let It Down" by George and a rare song by Colin "Where Did The Ordinary People Go?"
Skynnerd- they're like th' fuckin' 9/11 of music.
Chicago- more like th' Oklahoma city of music. Can't believe they name a city after them. Where's "Lightfoot" USA, I ask you?
Dylan- that old battleax needs to mumble 'n' shuffle his way into th' Ugly Porn idustry. Or off this mortal coil.
Yeh, th' Unraveling Dickburgers were bad news. Plus they killed Orbison. It's fact. They had all th' charisma of a sconce. Hee hee. A sconce.
Colin Moulding- I have a theory that he's amassing a stack of bitchin', funky neosoul supermodern psychedelic masterpieces that he's going to unleash in the next couple years and he's been chuckling and handing that weed partridge the worst tripe that he and his son write together and laugh their asses off.
Only bad people behave compulsively
Bobby, when you're on, you're on.
A sconce.
tlrvr Wtrwy n th lnd wtht vwls.
i just posted part of this at the viscount's site:
i do have to take exception to the 'bob dylan' (or any of the others listed) as a band your friend used to like but doesn't any more. the whole concept of 'not liking any more' is flawed. i think that what he (and you) mean is that you don't like what they are doing NOW. which is fine. but you surely can't be saying that just because you don't like who they are now, or how they are presenting themselves today in anyway makes their earlier works less compelling? artists go through phases, some get burned out early, or mid-career, or, like neil young, it seems never.
give these guys a break.
Well now that you mention it, I never really liked Dylan all that much.
mulox - new equine stomach medicine.
Post a Comment
<< Home